Q: What defenses can be used in a California DUI case?
In a California DUI case, several defenses may be available based on various legal arguments and evidential issues. One common defense is challenging the validity of the traffic stop. If law enforcement lacked reasonable suspicion to stop the vehicle, any evidence gathered thereafter may be deemed inadmissible. Additionally, the defense may scrutinize the administration and accuracy of field sobriety tests and breathalyzer or blood tests. Inaccuracies in calibration, maintenance records, or administration procedures can weaken the prosecution’s case against the defendant.
Another possible defense is the assertion of medical conditions that could produce false positives on sobriety tests. Some medical issues or medications may cause symptoms similar to intoxication or impair test results. If the defendant can provide relevant medical evidence, this might effectively challenge the DUI charge. Moreover, the defense could argue that the driver was not actually “driving”> under California law, as the statute specifies that actual physical control of the vehicle constitutes DUI. This requires proving that the defendant was operating the vehicle rather than simply being in the vehicle while under the influence.
It is crucial to understand the specific circumstances surrounding each case to determine the most viable defenses. Depending on the facts, defenses can also include mistake of fact, lack of intent, or challenges to the prosecution’s ability to prove the defendant’s blood alcohol concentration (BAC) was over the legal limit at the time of driving. Engaging with a knowledgeable attorney familiar with California DUI laws is vital to building an effective defense strategy.