Q: Can I appeal a DUI conviction based on new evidence?
In California, it is possible to appeal a DUI conviction based on new evidence, but there are specific legal criteria and procedures to follow. According to the information available, an appeal must generally be filed within a certain time frame after the conviction, typically within 60 days. It is important to file a Notice of Appeal promptly to preserve your right to challenge the conviction.
When presenting new evidence, it must be relevant and significant enough to potentially change the outcome of the trial. In many cases, new evidence may include witness statements, video footage, or other material that was not available during the initial trial. The appellate court will review whether this new evidence could have reasonably impacted the verdict. However, the evidence typically must not have been available at the time of the trial, and there must be a compelling argument that this evidence could have led to a different outcome.
If the new evidence does not warrant a straightforward appeal, you may also explore other legal avenues such as a motion for a new trial under California Penal Code Section 1181. This motion is filed in the original trial court and may succeed in instances where new evidence comes to light after a conviction that substantially sways the case’s merits. It is advisable to consult with an attorney experienced in DUI cases to effectively navigate the appeals process and assess the viability of your new evidence.